Creator Brands

Which channel keeps more per unit: wholesale or direct?

Enter the unit cost, your direct price and the wholesale price a retailer pays you, all excluding GST. You see what each channel keeps per unit and the direct price that would match the wholesale result. It helps before you agree to a retail listing.

What a customer pays you online for one unit, excluding GST, after any standing discount.

Share of direct revenue you expect to refund. Before launch this is an assumption, not a measured rate.

Your full cost per order, excluding GST. Do not include the delivery charge the customer pays.

Use 0 if this order came without paid advertising.

What the retailer pays you, not the shelf price. Excluding GST.

Expected damage credits, promotional allowances and deductions, as a share of the wholesale price.

Use the same cost in both channels, including the costs needed to make the unit saleable.

Result
Kept per direct unit after order costs–Per order, before fixed costs.
Kept per wholesale unit–Before any freight or account costs you agree to pay. Add those if they apply.
Direct advantage per unit–A negative figure means wholesale keeps more per unit with these inputs.
Direct price needed to match wholesale–Excluding GST, with the same order costs and refund rate.

Estimate based on your inputs. Per-unit estimate from your own figures, excluding GST, fixed costs, freight and cash timing. It is not financial or accounting advice.

How it works

  1. Enter the direct price and the wholesale price, both excluding GST, for the same saleable unit.
  2. Add expected refunds and credits as percentages, then the order costs for each channel.
  3. Each channel keeps its price less refunds or credits, less the unit cost. Direct also deducts its own order costs and advertising.
  4. Compare the two results. The direct price needed to match wholesale shows how far your price would have to move.

FAQ

How do I compare wholesale and direct margins per unit?

Take each channel's price after refunds or credits, then subtract the unit cost. Direct also subtracts order costs and advertising. With the example inputs, direct keeps 30 AUD and wholesale keeps 12.25 AUD per unit.

What direct price matches a wholesale price?

It is the wholesale amount kept, plus direct order costs and advertising, divided by 1 minus the refund rate. At the example inputs that is 81.32 AUD, so direct could sell well below 100 AUD and still match wholesale.

Why not compare the retailer's shelf price?

The shelf price is what the customer pays the retailer, not what you receive. Compare your wholesale price with your own direct price, both excluding GST, and add any freight or account costs to the wholesale side.

Related reading